Billions of liabilities missing from the balance sheet of Brazil's Lojas Americanas: Where was auditor PwC?
Auditors have to be either willfully blind or patently stupid to not realize billions are missing from balance sheets.
Update, Reuters, August 1, 2023:
Bellangero said that KPMG, which also handled accounting for Lojas Americanas and B2W before they merged to become Americanas in 2021, did not find fraud at either company from 2016 to 2019.
However, KPMG did find "deficiencies" in their control over a cooperative advertising budget, or when manufacturers and retailers share advertising costs, Bellangero said.
The firm flagged needed accounting improvements, including in the cooperative advertising budget, to Lojas Americanas' and B2W's finance chiefs in August 2019, Bellangero said.
Advertisement · Scroll to continue
"Since we didn't receive a response, we decided to issue an internal control letter to get management's attention," she added.
Six days later, Americanas terminated its contract with KPMG, Bellangero said. The company cited "business circumstances" as the reason.
This, unfortunately, is a well-known phenomenon.
On January 11, 2023, Americanas S.A., the parent company of Brazilian retailer Lojas Americanas announced that "inconsistencies" had been detected in the accounting entries related to amounts owed to suppliers over several years, including 2022. The company's initial estimate is that the amounts of "inconsistencies" could be as much as BRL 20 billion (about $3.9 billion at the current exchange rate) as of September 30, 2022. The source of the "inconsistencies" appears to be, according to a statement from the company, related the existence of purchase financing where Lojas Americanas owes approximately BRL 20 billion to financial institutions but those amounts are not reflected in the company's financial statements as of September 30, 2022.
Gustavo Henrique Ruffo at Autoevolution.com has the details:
Summing up, what happened was that the company bought from its suppliers with a 90-day deadline to pay. The suppliers sold this debt to banks at a discount in order to get their money faster. However, Lojas Americanas did not pay the banks, which turned into a snowball that reached the astronomical debt discovered by its new executives. Rial and Covre resigned immediately after finding out about the issue. The company is now worth only R$2.4 billion ($466 million), or around 12% of what it owes to banks.
On January 11, now former CEO Sérgio Rial spoke to analysts at a conference organized by Banco BTG Pactual. When one analyst asked what the ultimate impact of the "fraud" would be on the balance sheet and income statement and if there were other negative surprises looming, Rial responded that he didn't know, however he took exception the use of the word fraud:
Some of the entries put in place over a number of years were a mistake [but] the culture is not toxic. It has not been transparent but it is not toxic... Bonuses that were paid [for incorrect results] were reinvested in Americanas stock.
Despite this admittedly lukewarm vote of confidence in prior management, Sérgio Rial and new CFO André Covre, who with Rial recently took over on January 2, also announced their resignations from the company at the conference. Rial, who holds multiple boaord seats and is the former president of Santander Brasil, was announced in August of last year to replace Miguel Gutierrez, who had been at Americanas for almost 30 years and has been in charge of the group for 20 years. As a result of this sudden upheaval, the company said that its Board of Directors had appointed João Guerra as Chief Executive Officer and Director of Investor Relations on an interim basis.
The Board of Directors also created an independent committee to "determine the circumstances that caused said accounting inconsistencies". Rial is, however, just switching hats, and will take on a role as an advisor to billionaires Jorge Paulo Lemann, Marcel Telles, and Carlos Alberto Sicupira, founders of the Brazilian private equity firm 3G Capital, who've run Americanas until 2021 out of Rio de Janiero, since the 1980s. In 2021, a corporate restructuring reduced their interest from a controlling 53.3% stake to a "reference" shareholder stake of 29.2%. According to the Brazilian business magazine Folha, the trio increased this participation to 31.13% and are the main shareholders of Americanas.
3G Capital is also a major shareholder of US-listed companies AB Inbev, Kraft Heinz and Restaurant Brands International (which owns Burger King). Regular readers of The Dig will recall that in June of 2020 I wrote about a series of lawsuits filed as a result of the 2019 Kraft Heinz $15.4 billion goodwill impairment and an SEC investigation of 3G that eventually resulted in an enforcement action in September 2021 with a $62 million fine.
Initially filed on March 25th, 2021, much of the complaint had been redacted because of KHC’s request for confidentiality. However, I submitted a challenge to the Delaware Chancery Court about the level of redactions and KHC agreed to substantially narrow their scope of requested redactions.
Readers may also recall that PwC U.S. signs the audit opinion for Kraft Heinz and was also the auditor of both Kraft and Heinz before they merged in 2015.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Dig to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.